Your costs and CPI claims for Food @ Home costs Don’t Jive and Here’s why

\

Here is Why Your Grocery Bill Hurts Even When “Food at Home” CPI Claims Low Inflation

In her recent interview with @GrantWilliams, @DanielleDiMartinoBooth pointed out how the official “Food at Home” CPI category (groceries) has been showing very low or near-flat inflation lately — largely because households are cutting back and trading down aggressively.

Here’s the rub: CPI isn’t measuring what it costs to maintain your standard of living. It bakes in substitution — when you switch from steak to chicken, name brands to generics, or just buy less — and calls that “lower inflation.” Weak demand then forces retailers to slow price hikes, making the government’s number look better than reality for many families.

Latest data (April 2026):

• Food at Home CPI: around +2.9% YoY, with some months essentially flat
• Yet cumulative grocery prices are still up over 30% since 2020

Government statistics are working exactly as designed — to show inflation is “under control,” even when it doesn’t feel that way at the checkout line.

This is the disconnect: official averages versus real household pain. Especially for those who can’t keep substituting forever.

Thoughts? Are you buying the CPI narrative, or does it feel like polished fiction?